Abstract
We examine differences in behavior between subjects interacting with a member of either the same or different identity group in both a centipede game and a series of stag hunt games. We find evidence that subjects interacting with outgroup members are more likely to behave as though best-responding to uniform randomization of the partner. We conclude that group identity not only affects player[U+05F3]s social preferences, as identified in earlier research, but also affects the decision making process, independent of changes in the utility function.